Special Event: I Think Not! Live

Ellyn Marsh and Joey Taranto are bringing their hit true crime / comedy podcast “I Think Not!” to the stage! Join them on tour as they recap an episode of one of their (and your!) favorite true-crime TV shows. Ellyn and Joey are long-time friends from performing together on Broadway, so they’re obsessed with each other, trash TV, and all things true crime. Expect their signature mix of humor and heart (and let’s be honest, they will probably randomly break out into song) as they break down one of the wackiest cases from the best true crime series that campy television has to offer!


We are an 18+ venue.


Instead of a drink minimum, we have a two-item per person minimum in the Showroom, which can be fulfilled with any food or drink items from the menu.

Please Note: Food and drinks purchased in the bar and lounge do not count towards the two-item minimum.


  • General Admission seating is assigned on a first-come, first-sat basis as you enter the showroom. The earlier you arrive, the better your seats will be.

  • Reserved seats are assigned for you by management on the night of the show. They are the best seats available for your party size at the time they are assigned.

Please Note: We do not take seating requests and cannot guarantee seats in a specific location.


  • While we cannot guarantee seats together, General admission groups should arrive at least 45 minutes before showtime and enter the showroom as a group for the best chance of being seated together.

  • Reserved groups who purchase tickets in a single order will automatically be assigned seating together. Reserved ticket holders who purchase separately are not guaranteed seating together. Please see your email confirmation for details if your group purchased separately.

Please Note: Your group must enter the showroom together to be seated together. In addition, we do not take seating requests and cannot guarantee you seats in a specific location.


All sales are final. We do not offer refunds or exchanges.


Yes. Call our box office for more information. We encourage all patrons who have a disability to reach out to us to make accommodations.


Ticket protection is insurance that allows you to cancel your order to receive a venue credit toward a future event. It can be added to most orders at the time of purchase but cannot be added after the order has been placed.

To redeem your Ticket Protection and receive a venue credit toward a future event, please send an email to protection@heliumcomedy.com with your order number no less than 24 hours before showtime.

Please Note: Cancelation requests received via phone, chat, or less than 24 hours before showtime will not be accepted.




Have more questions? Visit our full FAQ page!



04/25/2024 8:00 PM
Other Showtimes

Special EventJoin Ellyn Marsh and Joey Taranto for an on-stage performance of their hit true crime and comedy podcast “I Think Not! Live.” Join them as they recap an episode of one of their (and your!) favorite true-crime TV shows.

Ellyn Marsh is an entertainer, artist, and comic. Ellyn had the pleasure of co-hosting the hit podcast “Obsessed with Disappeared” with two of her very best friends, first Patrick Hinds and Joey Taranto. Between the three of them, they completed nine seasons of the ID TV show “Disappeared”. Now she and Joey have created the show “I Think Not!” which combines what they do best. Unclear of what that is but once we find out, we will for sure let you all know.

Ellyn and Joey met backstage, wreaking havoc at the smash Broadway hit “Kinky Boots.” She also appeared on Broadway in "Pretty Woman," "Priscilla Queen of the Desert," and some plays (who sees those?). Ellyn recently was seen in the Disney movie “Better Nate Than Ever” and can also be heard as a singing troll in “Frozen.”

She’s bringing all of her musical theater references to the world of her other passion, true crime! After reporting on missing persons cases for three years, she’s decided to shake it up a bit with a variety of cases from classic true crime tv shows.

She also directs, writes, and edits a Broadway comedy podcast called “Gettin Peggy Wit It” where they roast Broadway stars. She’s the writer and creator of the web series “Turning the Tables” and the newly launched “Gallery View,” as well as the founder of Broadway Trivia League and can be seen making content on any platform that will give her a platform. She is also cohost of the podcast “Rabia and Ellyn Solve the Case” with Rabia Chaudry. Ellyn also is a voice and acting teacher for Broadway kids. Her students have been featured in Broadway shows such as Beetlejuice, Matilda, Annie, The Lion King, School of Rock and more!

After an incredible year of working on Obsessed with Disappeared, Joey is proud to continue his tour de gay alongside Ellyn’s clown parade with their new podcast, I Think Not!

Joey is a proud native of New Orleans (did you know he’s also a minister’s kid??) and loves bringing his southern roots and NOLA growl to the world of true crime. He, like Yellin’ Marsh, is a Broadway performer who made his debut in Rock of Ages.

He was also in the original companies of both Spider-Man: Turn off the Dark and Kinky Boots (with Yellin herself!). Joey has also been seen in Jesus Christ Superstar Live on NBC! And in 2022 he was featured in two critically acclaimed films: Chrissy Judy and BROS.

Now when it comes to the world of True Crime - Joey was a little bit of a novice, but has quickly found his footing. After all he is from the bayou and understands what it takes to hide a body. Not that he’s ever had to do that. Definitely not.

$75 pre-show Q&A experience with Ellyn and Joey, which includes a ticket to the show.


Management reserves the right to prevent customers from entering the facility who they deem disruptive or dangerous to other patrons.



We are an 18+ venue.


Instead of a drink minimum, we have a two-item per person minimum in the Showroom, which can be fulfilled with any food or drink items from the menu.

Please Note: Food and drinks purchased in the bar and lounge do not count towards the two-item minimum.


  • General Admission seating is assigned on a first-come, first-sat basis as you enter the showroom. The earlier you arrive, the better your seats will be.

  • Reserved seats are assigned for you by management on the night of the show. They are the best seats available for your party size at the time they are assigned.

Please Note: We do not take seating requests and cannot guarantee seats in a specific location.


  • While we cannot guarantee seats together, General admission groups should arrive at least 45 minutes before showtime and enter the showroom as a group for the best chance of being seated together.

  • Reserved groups who purchase tickets in a single order will automatically be assigned seating together. Reserved ticket holders who purchase separately are not guaranteed seating together. Please see your email confirmation for details if your group purchased separately.

Please Note: Your group must enter the showroom together to be seated together. In addition, we do not take seating requests and cannot guarantee you seats in a specific location.


All sales are final. We do not offer refunds or exchanges.


Yes. Call our box office for more information. We encourage all patrons who have a disability to reach out to us to make accommodations.


Ticket protection is insurance that allows you to cancel your order to receive a venue credit toward a future event. It can be added to most orders at the time of purchase but cannot be added after the order has been placed.

To redeem your Ticket Protection and receive a venue credit toward a future event, please send an email to protection@heliumcomedy.com with your order number no less than 24 hours before showtime.

Please Note: Cancelation requests received via phone, chat, or less than 24 hours before showtime will not be accepted.




Have more questions? Visit our full FAQ page!



Ellyn Marsh and Joey Taranto are bringing their hit true crime / comedy podcast “I Think Not!” to the stage! Join them on tour as they recap an episode of one of their (and your!) favorite true-crime TV shows. Ellyn and Joey are long-time friends from performing together on Broadway, so they’re obsessed with each other, trash TV, and all things true crime. Expect their signature mix of humor and heart (and let’s be honest, they will probably randomly break out into song) as they break down one of the wackiest cases from the best true crime series that campy television has to offer!